Thursday, June 16, 2005

Gay victims of Communism

A friend asked for information about gay men and lesbians who were victims of persecution in Communist countries. Unlike the Nazi case, where the fate of the "men with the pink triangles" is well-known, most of the comparable work on the gay victims of communism has yet to be done.

There is another imbalance. We know a fair amount about the theoretical bases of homophobia in Marxism and Marxist regimes, but relatively little about the actual persecution of gay and lesbian people.

Hubert Kennedy wrote an invaluable article on the personal homophobia of Marx and Engels, showing how they deployed innuendo of this kind in an effort to destroy a political opponent, Johann-Baptist von Schweitzer, who had been entrapped in a German public park. ("Johann-Baptist von Schweitzer: The Queer Marx Loved to Hate," Journal of Homosexuality, 29:2.3, 1995, pp. 69-96,) Other things being equal, this penchant might not have mattered, any more than, say, Marx's preference for Greek classical art over medieval art. During the 1920s, however, the world Communist movement began to adopt the rhetoric of decadence, including the idea that dying capitalism fosters perversion. Conversely, it is a feature of utopianism to exclude all sorts of things, from cabarets to street life, that the utopian thinkers regard as undesirable. Despite claims to the contrary, Marxism is a utopian, quasi-religious ideology. Some aspects of contemporary life were destined to find no place in Paradise.

In my view it would take an international committee to document the crimes of Communism against gay people. Yet there seems little appetite for this.

This is part of a larger asymmetry. As far as I know, none of the Stalinist criminals still alive in Russia has been brought to justice. Most of the gulag sites are disappearing, unlike Auschwitz, Buchenwald, and other places which have been rightly retained, at least in part, as a perpetual reminder of Nazi barbarism. There is still time to interview actual gay and lesbian victims of Communism. But not much more time.

Let me focus first on a country that is near at hand—Cuba. Sometimes I bring up the issues of the UMAP "reeducation" centers for gays in the sixties and seventies, and the enforced isolation of people with AIDS in the eighties. My interlocutors tend to respond: "Oh, that was a long time ago. Things are just fine now." They are not just fine. While the more overt measures of repression have ceased, discrimination persists. Being gay is not consistent with being a good Communist.

An atmosphere of "let bygones be bygones" prevails, no doubt reflecting the notion that Communism must be judged by its ostensibly noble ideals and not by its sordid practice. We are told that homophobia in Cuba reflects a confluence of Hispanic machismo and (ostensibly misunderstood) leftist puritanism. The principle blame, it seems, must be laid primarily at the door of the Spanish conquistadores. Such a view has been espoused by "El" himself (Fidel).

Another reason why people do not want to discuss past persecution and present discrimination applied to gays in Cuba is that this issue does not fit with the left-liberal narrative that the Cuban problem results entirely from the US embargo. We are supposed to engage constructivelye. Yet the Canadians and Europeans have found that does not work.

Together with North Korea, Cuba remains one of the two sole remaining orthodox Communist countries. Yet some shrink from even calling it Communist.

Internet sites on gays in Cuba are clogged by official Castroite propaganda alleging that all is well, and by small groups of pro-Castro gays, who serve the well-known function of useful idiots.

Fortunately there remains a book, by an honest leftist, Allen Young, Gays Under the Cuban Revolution (1981), if you can find it.

More generally, I think that the problem of documenting the oppression of gays under Communism needs to be divided into five sectors: 1) the former Soviet Union; 2) the Warsaw Pact countries of East-Central Europe; 3) the People's Republic of China; 4) Vietnam; and 5) Cuba.

In the rest of this posting I will only deal with the first. The Bolshevik Criminal Code of 1922 eliminated same-sex acts between adults. However, matters darkened in the late twenties, leading to full recriminalization in 1934. This pattern has been interpreted by gay Trotskyites as indicating that all was well under Lenin; it was Stalin's "aberration" that caused the difficulty. However, Simon Karlinsky has pointed to interviews with Lenin in which he indicated that all forms of sexual freedom were inimical to Marxism. In several articles Karlinsky did valiant work in opposing leftist myths, but I am not sure that he has kept up with the most recent developments.

On the site GAY.RU one can find a good piece by Igor Kon, a Russian sex researcher who moved to this country. Kon's earlier work was superficial, but this seems better. What I don't know is the extent that Russian gays were able to take advantage of the brief window of opportunity that opened in the archives post 1991.

A well documented episode is the visit of the great French writer André Gide to the Soviet Union in 1936. He went as a fellow traveler and returned deeply shaken. He wrote two books about the experience, the first circumspect, the second more outspoken about the social misery and absence of freedom of expression in the USSR. The Communists and their allies turned viciously on him. Some relied on innuendo, speaking of his problems with "morals" and his devotion to young men. The Communist pundit André Wurmser went further, producing a scurrilous article entitled "A Poor Bugger: André Gide." Another role, then, that homophobia played among Communists was to punish those who stepped out of line by advertising their proclivities. Something similar happened when Alger Hiss, after his exposure as a spy for the Soviets, sought to discredit his accuser Whitaker Chambers by talk about his homosexuality—-as if this had anything to do with the matter of Hiss' guilt.

17 Comments:

Blogger Free Traffic System said...

Hello,

I liked your blog. I found many interesting information here.
I also give free info about bank exchange foreign forex forex risk trading world.com on my
href="http://www.WebTradingSystem.com">Forex Trading System
site.

If you have time please visit my web site to get some free bank exchange foreign forex forex risk trading world.com
information.

Kind regards,
Nick

6:28 PM  
Blogger Danny White said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a guaranteed targeted web site traffic site/blog. It pretty much covers guaranteed targeted web site traffic related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time:-)

6:34 AM  
Blogger sdRay said...

San Diego is having a Hot Rod Halloween on Sunday, October 30. If you love classic hot rod truck then you will want to be there! All kinds of classic hot rod truck will be in attendance. For more information go to classic hot rod truck
See Ya There!!

10:45 AM  
Blogger pedro velasquez said...

The persecution of the gay Cuban novelist Reinaldo Arenas (1943-1990)sportsbook symbolises the worst homophobic excesses of Fidel Castro’s revolutionary Cuba: a period in the 1960s and 1970s when the witch-hunts of homosexuals in Cuba prefigured the oppression of gay Chileans during the Pinochet dictatorship.
Although Cuban queers are no longer savagely repressed, it is nonsense bet nfl for the Cuban government and its apologists in the West to claim there is no anti-gay discrimination in Cuba today.
It is true that Havana has none of the death squads that murder queers in Bogotá, but this is hardly proof of Castro’s liberalism.
Moreover, socialist Cuba may have the highest standards of health, education and housing of any Latin American country, and a literacy rate exceeding that of the United States. http://www.enterbet.com Great! But what is the point of excellent social welfare policies if people are not free and human rights are not respected?

3:07 PM  
Blogger Stivel Velasquez said...

Shortly afterward the columnist and essayist Katha Pollitt, writing in The Nation, advised him to calm down. "Kelly really should get out of the house more," she said. If he had attended the Washington march, as she did, he would have seen what a diverse and positive affair it was. costa rica vacation rentals She conceded that ANSWER was a "weird pseudomarxist sect," and she acknowledged its "off-key Stalinism and refusal to condemn Saddam Hussein," but she argued against taking any of that too seriously.
http://www.meadbrown.com

2:05 PM  
Blogger kimberly sayer said...

Gay activists are fuming over a legal brief filed last week by the Justice Department in support of the Defense of Marriage Act, saying it represents a break in President Obama's campaign promise to repeal the 1996 legislation. The Justice brief upholding DOMA was filed to Smelt v. United States, a California lawsuit brought by Arthur Smelt and Christopher Hammer asking the federal government to give them the same benefits as heterosexual couples.
offshore fishing,
manuel antonio,
salmon fishing,
sport fishing,
fishing guide.

http://www.fishingcostaricaexperts.com

8:48 AM  
Blogger pedro velasquez said...

Twenty years ago today, the Berlin Wall was breached and Soviet communism finally entered its death spiral. Sportsbook After claiming more than 100 million victims communism was dismissed to the ash heap of history. But the innocents who were enslaved, imprisoned, tortured, and killed under its demonic reign have largely been ignored, especially by the left and the liberals.Author and historian Lee Edwards set out to correct this oversight with the creation of the Victims of Communism memorial and online museum, march madness dedicated to those who perished because of Communist regimes between 1917 and 1989.
Reason.tv spoke to Edwards about the importance of historical memory, plans for a forthcoming bricks-and-mortar museum in Washington, DC, and the paintings of Ukrainian gulag survivor Nikolai Gettman, currently on display at the Heritage Foundation, where Edwards is a “Distinguished Fellow in Conservative Thought.
http://www.canadacasino.com

12:23 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Gay Activists Alliance was founded in New York City on December 21,1969 after the Stonewall riots, by dissident members of the Gay Liberation Front (GLF) including Sylvia Rae Rivera, Marsha P. Johnson, Jim Coles, Brenda Howard, Christopher Charles and Altan Zimbabwe,Costa rica tours who wanted to form a non-violent "single issue, politically neutral, militant organization" whose goal was to "secure basic human rights, dignity and freedom for all gay people.
http://www.kingtours.com

9:21 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The reason that gay men and lesbians became victims
of communism is because Adolf Hitler had bisexual
tendencies.

11:22 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

thanks for the update good istanbul
Zerrin Dogan Arsiv Yeşilçam Arşivlerini İzlemeye gelime iste harkülada turk yıldız zerrindogan

2:49 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice Blog!!! I thought I'd tell you about a site that will let give you places where
Kurdelenakıs ürünlerinden

2:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Karaca Kaan Yeşilçamın egzotik güzelinin arşivleri filmlerini bakmak gerikyor

2:57 AM  
Anonymous Penis Enlargement Pills said...

You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog.

7:53 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Not what I was searching for, but none the less and interesting blog here. Thanks for putting it up. I've enjoyed reading alot of the text here. I got you bookmarked for the future, I'll be back.


y8,y3,y8,miniclip,y8,pogo,friv,y3,
y8,android games,kizi,y8

3:58 PM  
Anonymous Costa Rica Fishing and Tours said...

Costa Rica Fishing
Hunter College Professor Wayne Dynes has a good piece on the gay victims of communism on his blog. Dynes acknowledges that he can only address the topic superficially, because little research has been done (or at least published) on how Marxist regimes persecuted (and continue to persecute) their gay and lesbian citizens.
Costa Rica Fishing and Tours

He offers this historical illustration of Communist attitudes toward homosexuality:

http://costa-ricafishing.com/
A well documented episode is the visit of the great French writer André Gide to the Soviet Union in 1936. He went as a fellow traveler and returned deeply shaken. He wrote two books about the experience, the first circumspect, the second more outspoken about the social misery and absence of freedom of expression in the USSR.Costa Rica Fishing
The Communists and their allies turned viciously on him. Some relied on innuendo, speaking of his problems with "morals" and his devotion to young men. The Communist pundit André Wurmser went further, producing a scurrilous article entitled "A Poor Bugger: André Gide." Another role, then, that homophobia played among Communists was to punish those who stepped out of line by advertising their proclivities. Costa Rica Fishing and Tours
Something similar happened when Alger Hiss, after his exposure as a spy for the Soviets, sought to discredit his accuser Whitaker Chambers by talk about his homosexuality—-as if this had anything to do with the matter of Hiss' guilt. http://costa-ricafishing.com/

4:37 PM  
Blogger Flash New Games said...

If you have time please visit my web site to get some free maximize web site traffic information.

y8 Paint Games Kids Games Friv Car Games Ben10 Games addicting Games

4:29 PM  
Anonymous starfall said...

Thanks for putting it up. I've enjoyed reading alot of the text here. I got you bookmarked for the future, I'll be back. Nice post ! I would like to say that this blog really convinced me, you give me best information! Thanks, very good post. It is a wonderful time to enjoy more with fun game online at :


friv3play.net
friv10play.net
y8y8y8.games

8:23 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home